Talk of the possible link between the reviews and Harmonix surfaced on the /r/games subreddit on Wednesday. A few Redditors posted screenshots of reviews with authors that appeared to be Harmonix employee. A Destructoid post later confirmed a few of the names were employees of the developer:
Harmonix’s statement suggested that employees had done this of their own accord, and that it did not support such actions:
Discussions on the Reddit thread centered around whether the studio had pushed employees to review the game, hoping nobody would notice who wrote them, or if the employees genuinely liked the game so much as to give it a five-star review liked the game so much because they actually felt that way.
Both are plausible explanations. It makes sense that employees working on a game for a couple of years would be invested in its success. And the financial futures of co-developers Harmonix and Mad Catz’s are very invested in how well Rock Band 4 does in the coming months.
Since the response by Harmonix, many of the identified employees have deleted their reviews, with at least one, Matthew Nordhaus, adding a lengthy clarification to his review.
This isn’t the first time employees have been caught reviewing their own company’s games. In 2011, a nearly identical situation took place with Dragon Age 2, when a couple of BioWare employees submitted glowing reviews of the game to Metacritic. A later statement from Electronic Arts, which owns BioWare, defended the practice.
Harmonix statement reported via Destructoid.
